We might be surprised to learn that Russian hockey coaches have taught in much the same way as violin or piano or golf instructors. They believe that fundamental skills must be rehearsed perfectly over and over again; thereby eliminating poor technique before it becomes a habit. They are adamant that skill practice is a pre-requisite to competition for at least three years. Poor technique is likely to occur during games, and sloppy habits will never lead to improved skills.
It's a simple formula. We’d almost like to think there’s something more secretive, but this is how they develop an abnormally high number of world-class violin players in Novosibirsk -- tennis players at Spartak -- hockey stars at Dynamo. This is probably why the South Korean women golfers are becoming such a force on the LPGA tour; they have very few golf courses, so they practice fundamentals at the driving range more than young players in other countries.
In the United States, we might say, "Repetition after repetition is boring, and I want kids to have fun." The Russians would answer, "Our kids do have fun. They can't wait to do repetitions on-ice and off, feel the improvement, and have success in competition."
No one can deny that it'd be a lot of fun to have skills like Ovechkin, Kovalchuk, or Tiger Woods -- or for that matter, Itzhak Perlman, or any great musician in the world. Their childhoods were not boring. Passion wasn't lost because of their early specialization.
If a youngster is bored with hockey and wants to quit, it's probably from lack of skills to compete successfully -- not from over-emphasis on correct technique. We think we’re making the experience fun with games that amount to grand productions -- but in fact, competing without skill is a surefire path to lost confidence and withdrawal -- the grander the production, the greater the feelings of inadequacy.
Recent scientific studies have shown that learning a motor skill -- just like learning to read or do math -- involves the "white matter" of the brain and spinal cord -- the myelin insulation produced by glial cells (see below). Increased white matter is related to elevated IQ and refined motor skills. More importantly, myelin increases with quality repetition.
How does ‘learning’ occur at the cellular level? See below.
One important note: This discussion is not about building world-class athletes. It's about having the most fun possible in hockey. Improving skills is the first step.