Greenblatt 1995

Reference:

Under construction

Review

Excerpts

'"Culture" is a term that is repeatedly used without meaning much of anything at all, a vague gesture toward a dimly perceived ethos' (228).

Domains: Under construction |

Key Terms: | culture | meaning | term |



'Here we can make our first tentative move toward the use of culture for the study of literature... to recover a sense of the stakes that once gave readers pleasure and pain. An awareness of culture as a complex whole can help us to recover that sense by leading us to reconstruct the boundaries upon whose existence the works were predicated.... What kinds of behavior, what models of practice, does this work seem to enforce? Why might readers at a particular time and place find this work compelling? Are there differences between my values and the values implicit in the work I am reading? Upon what social understandings does the work depend? Whose freedom of thought or movement might be constrained implicitly or explicitly by this work? What are the larger social structures with which these particular acts of praise or blame might be connected?' (?227).

Domains: Under construction |

Key Terms: | culture | implicit | reading | study | thought |



'Cultural analysis has much to learn from scrupulous formal analysis of literary texts because those texts are not merely cultural by virtue of reference to the world beyond themselves; they are cultural by virtue of social values and contexts that they have themselves successfully absorbed....Cultural analysis must be opposed on principle to the rigid distinction between that which is within a text and that which lies outside' (227).

Domains: Under construction |

Key Terms: | analysis | distinction | literary | reference | text | world |



'If culture functions as a structure of limits, it also functions as the regulator and guarantor of movement. Indeed the limits are virtually meaningless without movement; it is only through improvisation, experiment, and exchange that cultural boundaries can be established. Obviously, among different cultures there will be a great diversity in the ratio between mobility and constraint. Some cultures dream of imposing an absolute order, a perfect stasis, but even these, if they are to reproduce themselves from one generation to the next, will have to commit themselves, however tentatively or unwillingly, to some minimal measure of movement; conversely, some cultures dream of an absolute mobility, a perfect freedom, but these too have always been compelled, in the interest of survival, to accept some limits' (228-9).

Domains: Under construction |

Key Terms: | absolute | constraint | culture | ratio | structure |



'This mobility is not the expression of random motion but of exchange' (229).

Domains: Under construction |

Key Terms: | expression |



'Great works of art are not neutral relay stations in the circulation of cultural materials. Something happens to objects, beliefs and practices when they are represented, reimagined, and performed in literary texts, something often unpredictable and disturbing. That "something" is the sign both of the power of art and of the embeddedness of culture in the contingencies of history' (230-1).

Domains: Under construction |

Key Terms: | culture | history | literary | power | sign |



Referring to Shakespeare's The Tempest, Greenblatt advances that 'If it is the task of cultural criticism to decipher the power of Prospero, it is also its task to hear the accents of Caliban'. The critic's job is to notice that contradictory elements of the author's world are being juxtaposed in the author's work to bring to light significant conflict and make statements about the world. In this kind of reading, Prospero represents the imperialism of European exploration of the New World and Caliban represents the right of the people of the New World to self-determination. (232).

Domains: Under construction |

Key Terms: | criticism | power | reading | world |



Last Modified: July-12-96 9:23:44

Reply to randy_radney@sil.org

[A Lexicon of the Humanities | SIL Home Page | Contributions]