my pumpkin can read
 
Okay, well maybe not yet.  But when the Parent Bloggers Network offers me the chance to try something that holds out the promise of not having to read the same book to my darling toddlergirl over—and over—and over—and over again, and via DVD no less, well, I’m gonna jump at the chance.  Plus, my daughter’s a genius, right?  I mean, I may have mentioned that here once or twice before.
 
Your Baby Can Read! is a series of DVDs which basically enact a multimedia version of interactive flashcards for your baby or toddler to absorb, interact with, and learn from.  We were provided with the starter DVD, meant to be viewed for a month, Volume 1, meant to be viewed for 2 months, and a pack of 5 cool double-sided slider flashcards (complete with a blank whiteboard card and a dry-erase marker to make your own flashcard).
 
Your Baby Can Read!  The title alone activates the competitive alpha-parent deep inside you, the one who secretly gloats when your kid does stuff first before older ones in your social circle.  “I want my baby to read!”  We live in a test-to-death, No Child Left Behind Except Yours world, and it’s hard not to let some of that seep in after reading the umpteenth parentblog post about freakin’ pre-school applications.  Countless products hold out the promise that if you let your kid read/watch/play with their entire line of stuff, your kid will become like that famous physics dude with the gnarly hair.
 
This, however, is a little different.  Dr. Titzer’s program seems to fuse ideas about language acquisition from both whole language- and phonics-based pedagogies and multiple intelligence theory [sorry, ex-teacher, can’t help the ed-speak!], and you know what?  It makes sense.  The basic idea is repeated exposure to the written word and explicit connection to its sound and meaning.  Makes sense—a toddler can learn by repetition that, say, the written word “elephant” means that big funny animal that’s in so many of her picture books and that it sounds like, well, I’d do a phonetic spelling but I don’t know how to make the schwa symbol on the computer.  But anyway, the idea is that a kid can move from recognizing that whole written word and connecting it to both sound and meaning to being able to, down the line, read new and unfamiliar words based on an understanding of those building blocks (letters, syllables, phonemes, whatever).  Again, makes sense.  I remember being amazed when my nephew, who’s now a tween, was a toddler and could tell us what channel the TV was on because he knew all the word-and-graphic logos.
 
Titzer adds in multiple intelligence theory for good measure—recognizing that different people learn in different ways and that tapping into, say, one’s visual, auditory, and kinesthetic (that is to say, physical) intelligences all at once will reinforce the material and the processes being taught.  So on the DVDs, your kid will see the written word, hear the spoken word, be invited to say the word, sing the word, act out the word, et cetera.  
 
Again, it all makes sense, and it probably does work, and I bet it would work for The Pumpkin.  After all, I was worried, when she started “reading” the letters of the alphabet from one particular book, that she might have trouble extrapolating the knowledge to, say, different cases or typefaces.  But she’s done fine, and can now recognize her own name (and, of course, the favorite word of toddlerhood, “no,”) no matter the font or if certain letters are capitalized or not.  Also, I’m reminded of our short-lived attempt at baby sign language.  After trying to keep up with the repetition for a handful of signs, like “milk” and “more” and “all done,” we gave up, thinking she’d picked up none of it.  Months later, she busted out with the signs—though, of course, it took her dense parents a little while to figure out that that was what it was.
 
But as a newly-returned-to-the-traditionally-defined-workplace former-at-home-parent, I just think that this program might be a little hard to fit in.  The instructions recommend that your child view the DVDs twice a day, and that you view them with her for reinforcement and interaction.  I totally agree—it just ain’t gonna happen.  Though The Pumpkin loves the theme music (which I wish would run underneath the entire video, at least the flashcard parts), and she loves the sing-alongs, and though she does participate with the word recitations, at least in the beginning, it’s too easy for her to get distracted or disinterested and leave.  It’s more something to watch when I can sit with her and read and sing alongside her—however, I can reliably set her up with a TiVo’d episode of Sesame Street and, because of the action and the characters and the storylines (and the repeition), I know she’ll stick around and stay out of the kitchen where I’m trying to cook dinner.  I think the pedagogy underlying Your Baby Can Read actually proves unnecessary the usual admonition that Sesame Street isn’t for babies or young toddlers (unless, of course, you’re a “no TV for said age group” adherent)—they actually can pick up on the vocab lessons and the printed-words-on-the-screen.  See?  That way, at least, when the “TV or not TV” question comes up, at least I have the excuse that I only let her watch edjumacational programs, and kids who grow up on The Street are geniuses!  Heh.
 
Regardless of how much time you can spend watching the DVDs, or how long you can get your kid to sit through some of the drier bits [I mean, there’s only so much excitement you can add to what are basically televised flashcards], I have to mention that The Pumpkin’s favorite part of the entire system were the nicely designed, but decidedly lower-tech, double-sided slider flashcards.  She loves these things, dude—takes them in her stroller for our walks with the dog, even.  And that dry-erase card is the best.  “Daddy, write ‘Pumpkin.’”  “Daddy, write ‘Mama.’”  “Write ‘Daddy,’ Daddy.”  She loves the built-in eraser on the marker cap, too.  [Oh, and since I can’t fit it in anywhere, else, let me just say how happy I was to see the diversity of the young cast in Volume 1.  After the Starter DVD, starring basically the good doctor’s family, I was getting a little worried, but it was all good—though nobody who looked like The Pumpkin.  Maybe in Volume 2.]
 
So, can she “read” yet?  No, not yet.  But, while I’m not totally convinced of the immediate utility of learning to recognize the written forms of, say, “gorilla” and the aforementioned “elephant,” this is definitely another useful tool in the literacy development box.  You’ve to have the print-rich environment first [sorry, it’s the ed-speak again—but basically, surround your kid in text, all kinds—and recognize that not everybody has that luxury], and you’ve got to read to them, to instill in them a love of reading and the written word [that’s not somebody else’s job].  The Pumpkin’s favorite playground is the local bookstore.  [If you work there, sorry, I really do mean to put back everything she takes off the shelf, but, well, you know...  Toddlers.]  I cannot wait until the day she doesn’t need me to read to her whatever adventures she finds there.
 
 
Thursday, March 15, 2007