Morgan Worthy

The following is offered not as a formal theory, but only as a framework or illustration to show how different skills or traits related to eye darkness may lead to different hunting strategies.

Among land vertebrates, those predators most skilled at catching mobile prey tend to have either yellowish eyes or eyes that are dark brown or black. Their hunting strategies differ. A yellow-eyed predator’s first response to mobile prey is to wait without moving; that is the first step in a successful ambush. A black-eyed  predator’s first response to mobile prey is to move without waiting; that is the first step in a successful direct pursuit.  Predators with  eye colors near the midrange between yellow and black (e.g. red or light brown) appear to be  unskilled at either ambush hunting or direct pursuit hunting; they tend to find prey that is immobile or ignored by other predators for some reason (noxious, toxic, deep underwater, etc.). 

To expand on that and include the full range of eye-darkness, the hunting behavior may change as species eye color (or average eye-darkness for subfamilies, families, etc.) changes from yellow to orange to red to brown to black. The numbers below each color are estimates of relative eye-darkness on a scale from 0 to 1.

    
         .00                     .25                      .50                     .75                     1.00

Predator Eye Color            Hunting Technique

Black                                 Immediate direct pursuit from a moving start
                                             (e.g. aerial flycatching as seen in swifts, swallows,             
                                                and evening bats)

Brown                               Immediate direct pursuit from a standing start
                                            (e. g. aerial flycatching from an exposed perch as   
                                                seen in tyrant-flycatchers)

Red                                    Foraging for immobile prey
                                            (e.g. gleaning dormant insects or larvae as seen in  
                                                woodpeckers)

Orange                              Delayed ambush from a moving start
                                              (e. g. active looking for prey which is then 
                                                 stalked or surprised  as seen in harmless snakes, 
                                                    some hawks, and civets/mongooses)

Yellow                               Delayed ambush from a standing start
                                               (e.g. lying-in-wait or very slow stalking as is often                                            
                                                   seen in frogs, true vipers, herons and cats)
                              
                                        
To repeat, the above is offered only to illustrate some of the ways that gradations in eye darkness may be related to subtle differences in hunting behavior. The true picture is much more complex and includes special hunting strategies such as taking  toxic prey avoided by other predators or swimming underwater to find prey.
Sep 21, 2008
 Eye Color and Predator Behavior
IRISPIGMENTATION.COM